Blog
Sooner or later, someone at home asks why the household cooks for two days when a restaurant could wash the pans. That person has a strong case, because Chicago restaurants open on Thanksgiving Day cover everything from carved prime rib to turkey with mole.
The harder part is choosing, since a riverfront buffet and a shared Southern meal make for two very different Thursdays. This guide sorts the best restaurants for Thanksgiving dinner in Chicago by the kind of meal you want. Menus, prices, and hours change from one year to the next, so please confirm the details when you book.
Tortoise Supper Club on North State Street suits families who want the full spread in a Jazz Age dining room. Its buffet centers on hand-carved turkey and prime rib, with an iced seafood tower on the side. The restaurant also has valet parking, which helps on a cold night.
River Roast brings the same buffet idea to the riverfront. This format also settles the oldest argument of the day, because a grandparent can choose the roast while a teenager heads for dessert.
Anyone who privately prefers crab to turkey should look at Shaw’s Crab House in River North. It usually serves a traditional plate with all the trimmings alongside its seafood, so nobody has to choose between the two.
The restaurant also tends to serve from midday into the evening, which covers both late lunches and early dinners. Suburban families can try the Shaw’s location in Schaumburg, which serves its own holiday menu.
Hawksmoor is the option for people who would rather have prime rib than turkey. Its River North kitchen carves a dry-aged roast to order and adds British trimmings such as Yorkshire pudding.
For something more formal, RPM Steak on West Kinzie usually runs a multi-course prix fixe, with fish and beef among the mains. This is the pick for a plated dinner with no carving station in sight.
Cindy’s sits on the 13th floor of the Chicago Athletic Association hotel on South Michigan Avenue. Its glass atrium and terrace overlook Millennium Park, the Art Institute and Lake Michigan. Most diners will prefer the atrium in late November.
Couples and small parties fit this room well, and it helps to ask whether the holiday menu is à la carte or set. Sunset falls around 4:30 p.m. at that point in the year, which makes a mid-afternoon reservation the best one for those windows.
Andersonville’s Big Jones marks the holiday with a shared Southern meal. Ask about the seating options when you call, because they can affect the price of a large table.
Diners who eat later can look at Somerset, the restaurant inside the Viceroy hotel in the Gold Coast. An evening table works well if your relatives want to spend the afternoon together and sit down once the football is over.
Some families want the holiday but not the usual menu.
The Chicago Thanksgiving Parade is the first surprise. It runs up State Street that morning, and closures around the Loop can last well past the final float, so check them first. Tables downtown feel this most, while River North sits beyond the route. A noon reservation therefore needs extra time. Getting a large party to a special occasion also takes more arranging that day. The Chicago Transit Authority has run a Sunday timetable on the holiday in the past, so look up train times too.
The second surprise is how early the day ends. Many restaurants take their final reservations earlier than on a normal Thursday, and a few serve only lunch. A family that eats late at home should ask about the last seating.
The right table depends on who is coming and how they like to eat. Pick the setting your family will enjoy and call early.
Families with relatives flying in or driving from several suburbs tend to settle how they all get there and back when they book. That leaves the rest of the day for seconds and long conversations, and nobody has to watch the clock.